hi i don’t go here anymore but sam winchester looks at the boy who’s father abused and raped him for thousands of years and doesn’t hesitate to believe in him, to trust him, to not hold his father’s actions against him, even though he must sometimes look at jack and see the reminder of the archangel who humiliated and broke him, sam never takes that trauma out on jack, never blames him or guilt trips him, only treats him with dignity and patience and empathy, and if that isn’t the makings of one of the best men on the planet, i don’t know what is.
Dean’s body was rebuilt when he was raised from Hell, but Sam’s wasn’t. What if, once he got his soul and his memory back, his body couldn’t forget what had happened in Hell? How high would his pain threshold be?
~~~
“I’m just going to tuck this warmed blanket around you,” she says. (Ashley, her name is Ashley; the whiteboard on the wall across from him says Baptist Medical Center Emergency Department and Your nurse is Ashley and Today is Wednesday the 22nd and other things they think he wants to know.)
(You are topside. That’s what Sam wants to know.)
“I know you’ve got to be freezing,” she continues. (Ashley, she’s Ashley. Remember. Focus.) He looks at her, puzzled. Freezing? He’s a little cold, maybe, but not uncomfortably so. Falling into a frozen lake isn’t cold. Not like the feeling of Lucifer pressed against him, hand plunged into his chest and curled possessively around his heart, turning his blood to ice in his veins. Compared to that, nothing up here is actually cold.
Behind Ashley, Dean raises his eyebrows briefly and then looks pointedly at the skin of his exposed arm. Oh. Goosebumps. Empirical evidence that he is, in fact, cold. But that’s good. Empirical data is good. It’s better than trying to guess what he’s feeling.
“Thanks, Ashley,” he says. He smiles. He is okay. He is okay.
“Now, how bad is your pain, on a scale of one to ten? If one is no pain at all, and ten is the worst pain you can imagine, where would you put your current level of pain?”
(He doesn’t imagine, he remembers, and he is struck dumb with the effort of not remembering.)
When he doesn’t immediately answer, Ashley says “It’s okay. Don’t worry that we’re not going to give you anything if you don’t give us the right number. My goal is for you to have no pain at all. So, if one is no pain, and ten is being boiled in oil, how much pain are you in right now?
On the whiteboard, a row of cartoon faces demonstrates pain levels one through ten. Face number one is smiling, happy. Face number ten has a mouth curved down into a dramatic frown, fat cartoon tears leaking from its eyes.
(Its eyes have not been gouged out. Its mouth is not stretched open in a desperate agonized scream.)
Ashley doesn’t know what being boiled in oil feels like, and neither does face number ten, but Sam does. If being boiled in oil is a ten on Ashley’s scale, having your spine ripped out through your mouth must be a fifteen. Having slivers of glass scrape down every nerve in your body simultaneously is a twenty.
(Sam can count very, very high.)
How does this scale calibrate to real pain? What is a broken arm supposed to feel like? Should falling through ice into a frozen lake afterward make it hurt more, or less?
Behind Ashley (her name makes him shudder, ash and brimstone and fire and ice and claws and teeth), Dean clears his throat, holds his hands at waist level. Five fingers extended on his left hand, one on his right.
“Six,” Sam says. “I’m at a six.” Dean smiles, gives him a quick nod. (You are topside.)
Face number six isn’t smiling. Sam fixes his mouth into a slight frown to match face number six.
“All right,” Ashley says. “I’m going to talk to the doc, and he’ll order something for your pain. Then we’ll get you in for X-rays.”
Sam nods, tries to concentrate on the distant ache of his broken bones and not the sharp sense-memory of being burned boiled skewered shattered dismembered.
“Thank you, Ashley.”
He is okay.
~~~
(Inspired by a nurse who actually used the “boiled in oil” analogy. The title is from “Human” by The Human League .)
dean got to torture alistar, but sam is supposed to buck up, “sympathize” and work with the archangel who tortured him so badly that his mind couldn’t handle it and his body started shutting down??? ok 🐸☕️
Standing toe-to-toe with the Devil in the cage, after being taunted and having all of his insecurities and regrets laid out in front of him…still looked Lucifer in the eye and refused. Refused to let himself be manipulated and showed just how much faith he has in his family despite all of the odds being stacked against them.
I think Sam is somewhat suicidal but he’s been to heaven, hell, and purgatory and heaven was a disappointment, hell was the cage, and purgatory was hunting.
He’s got no place to go.
That’s not even mentioning the Empty. You know…the place where he and Dean will probably be forced to end after they die, because of the reapers.
How devastating it must be when anywhere you go turns into inescapable hell? When you know that even taking your own life will not bring you oblivion?
Does Sam even wish for peace after death, or is that hope long gone? Maybe he just wants complete oblivion, to dissapear from existence, but no, the universe (the reapers) can’t give him even that little.
Brings new meaning to the “It ends bad” line, doesn’t it?
don’t think about how terrible it must have been for Sam to be strapped to that table in the padded cell in Sam, Interrupted. don’t think about him remembering being strapped to a table in When the Levee Breaks. don’t think about him wondering if he was actually there again.
Rowena: How do you deal with [your memories of Lucifer]? Sam: I guess I don’t…deal with it. Not really. I mean… I’ve pushed it down and I… The world kept almost ending, so I keep pushing it down. I don’t know… I don’t really talk about it. Not even with Dean. I mean, I could. You know, he’s listen, but… It’s not something I really know how to share. Even if you do get the book. Even if you do get your power back, it won’t matter. You won’t ever be able to change what happened. You won’t be able to change how helpless you felt. Or how helpless you feel. You’re still going to get scared… and that feeling… that feeling never goes away. Rowena: Never? Sam: Never.
Maybe you tie them to a chair. Maybe you do worse. So, maybe… maybe you can go to hell.
#sam has that way of being defiant and vulnerable at the same time #hes so brave but it hurts (via @wetsammywinchester)
I always assume that when Sam or Dean tells someone to go to hell there’s the weight of experience behind it.
I was thinking about this, too. “Go to hell” is generally such a mild curse. Both the boys toss it around in earlier seasons, as you might expect. But in later seasons it feels like Sam says it only very rarely, and only to people he despises.
Following this instinct, I just looked up when else Sam has told someone to go to hell since season 7.
As it turns out, he’s said it two other times. Both times were in s12. Both times were to Lucifer.